Cream(er) of the Crop: Scouting Out the Highest Rated Coffee Makers

For a true java lover, the type of coffee maker you use really can make all the difference. So when it comes time to buy a new one, doing your homework is worth the effort. But…what post-adolescent has time for homework these days? That’s where we come in. We know you’ve got other stuff to worry about, so we’re gonna let you copy our notes.

BUNN ST Velocity Brew 10-Cup Thermal Carafe Home Coffee Brewer

BUNN ST Velocity Brew 10-Cup Thermal Carafe Home Coffee Brewer

Before that though, you will need to do a tiny bit of self-analysis. Otherwise, how will you know when you’ve found the coffee maker that’s right for you? Ask yourself the tough questions, such as, well, what kind of coffee do you like, how fast do you want it, and what kind of price point are you comfortable with? Of course, coffee makers come in all colors and shapes, at all price points and functionalities, and from hundreds of manufacturers. But only one is the one for you. So how to decide?

We think it’s a little like choosing a mechanic. A recommendation from someone you trust can be far more telling than expensive advertising, whether it’s for your car maintenance or for your next coffee maker And that’s why we’ve sifted through the reviews for you, to bring you the intel on four of today’s highest rated coffee makers.

Here they are, in no particular order:

Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffeemaker ($40): For those with a penchant for room service, this elegant (and easy) coffee maker will look pretty familiar. With its graceful curvature, Presto’s percolator looks more like an antique silver pitcher than a complicated appliance. It churns out up 4-12 cups of coffee (one cup per minute), then an indicator light flicks on to let you know it’s ready. Survey says: easy as pie.

BUNN ST Velocity Brew 10-Cup Thermal Carafe Home Coffee Brewer ($229): Interested in a more modern look? This no-nonsense stainless steel pick brews 4-10 cups of coffee in four minutes. The double-wall, insulated carafe then keeps it hot for another two hours. And as for flavor, you can make it as strong or light as you like—the stainless steel keeps the water tank at a precise 200 degrees. After that, a unique sprayhead evenly applies said hot water consistently over the grounds for flavor extraction that, survey says, is just right.

Toddy T2N Cold Brew System ($40): Prefer your cuppa joe to pack a little less acid than the typical coffee maker brew? This well-reviewed cold-brew system doesn’t even need electricity to brew up flavorful coffee concentrate, which stays fresh for up to three weeks. Survey says: plenty of bang for your buck. (Want more info on cold brew coffee? Check out our recent post on Cold Brewed Coffee Makers.)

Mr. Coffee BVMC-FM1 20-Ounce Frappe Maker ($80): Okay, so this is not technically a coffee maker…but mocha and latte lovers will love the convenience factor of this user-friendly contraption. Combining typical coffee-brewing functions with high-powered blender capabilities, this Mr. Coffee offering enables you to make your own coffeehouse-style drinks at home in just three minutes. Survey says: bottoms up.

And there you have it. Some of today’s highest rated coffee makers are just a click away. Happy shopping!

Leave a Comment